Review Of "Woodpeckers Of North America" By F. Backhouse

Document Type

Book Review

Publication Date

6-1-2006

Published In

Choice

Abstract

Freelance writer Backhouse provides an in-depth look at a popular group of birds, using informative text and superb photographs and drawings. The first half of the volume treats general topics including anatomy, behavior, ecology, and conservation in a clear style at a level similar to that of an introductory biology textbook; the second half gives detailed species accounts of all North American woodpeckers. The language is nontechnical and engaging. The book includes a brief index, glossary, and three-page bibliography. Although at first glance this volume appears to be a much-needed monograph on woodpeckers, the lack of detailed references or a substantial bibliography makes this work problematic for academic libraries. Readers have no way of judging whether the book's factual material is anecdotal, conjectural, or supported by peer-reviewed data. Its inclusion in a reference collection would send the wrong message to students about the very nature of science and scholarship. Most libraries would be better off with a good ornithology textbook such as F. Gill's Ornithology (3rd ed., 2004) and the series The Birds of North America, ed. by A. Poole (CH, Oct'93, 31-0635) and now available online (CH, Nov'05, 43-1297). Summing Up: Recommended. General readers.

Comments

This work is freely available courtesy of Choice Reviews. The review has been reproduced in full in the abstract field.

This document is currently not available here.

Share

COinS