A Replication Of Stern, West, And Schmitt (2014) Indicates Less False Consensus Among Liberals Than Conservatives, But No False Uniqueness
Stern, West, and Schmitt (2014) reported that liberals display truly false uniqueness in contrast to moderates and conservatives who display truly false consensus. We conducted a close, preregistered replication of Stern et al.’s (2014) research with a large sample (N = 1,005). Liberals, moderates, and conservatives demonstrated the truly false consensus effect by overestimating ingroup consensus. False consensus was strongest among conservatives, followed by moderates, and weakest among liberals. However, liberals did score higher than moderates and conservatives on the need for uniqueness scale, which partially accounted for the difference in false consensus between liberals and conservatives. Overall, our data align with Stern et al.’s (2014) in demonstrating left-right ideological differences in the overestimation of ingroup consensus but fall short of illustrating a liberal illusion of uniqueness.
political ideology, false consensus effect, need for uniqueness, left-wing politics, replication
John C. Blanchar; Michael Alonzo , '22; Christine Ayoh , '21; Kali Blain , '22; Leslie Espinoza , '22; Marcos Estrada , '22; Jared A. Gillen , '20; Atziri Marquez , '22; Joanne Miao , '22; Victoria Overbeck , '21; Camryn Slosky , '22; Shruthi Srivatsan , '22; Elise Talley , '21; and Justin Tucker , '22.
"A Replication Of Stern, West, And Schmitt (2014) Indicates Less False Consensus Among Liberals Than Conservatives, But No False Uniqueness".