Document Type


Publication Date


Published In



Philip Kitcher recently argued for a reconstruction in philosophy. According to him, the contemporary mainstream of philosophy (in the English-speaking world, at least) has deteriorated into something that is of relevance only to a few specialists who communicate with each other in a language nobody else understands. Kitcher proposes to reconstruct philosophy along two axes: a knowledge axis (with a focus on the sciences) and a value axis. The present article discusses Kitcher's diagnosis as well as his proposal of a therapy. It argues that there are problems with both, and it ends with an alternative view of what some core problems of the profession currently are.


This work is a preprint freely available courtesy of Wiley, Metaphilosophy LLC, and Blackwell Publishing.

The final publication version can be freely accessed courtesy of Wiley's Content Sharing service.

Included in

Philosophy Commons